NYTimes columnist Nick Bilton wrote today that he’s seeing massive declines in organic Facebook engagement on his posts. He cites last year receiving hundreds of likes per post but now having 1/10th that despite growing subscribers 20x. The hypothesis is that Facebook is suppressing distribution in order to encourage paid promotion, which would be consistent with their business model. Facebook of course denies making newsfeed adjustments to juice revenue.
- Facebook has gotten better at spam fighting. The previous “likes” could have come from bots or other spam techniques. What he’s seeing now is actual engagement
- Facebook’s user engagement hasn’t kept up with volume of graph growth and newsfeed publishing. That’s to say, users are “liking” the same # of posts per day, but there are so many more posts in their newsfeed due to having more friends, subscribing to other pages that each friend gets fewer likes per item. Lots of apps/sites publishing into feeds now.
- Secondary effect of ad models. Over the past year more of my feed has become sponsored/promoted. This pushes organic down the page, especially on mobile where app install promoted spots take up so much real estate.
- Impact of mobile. Although the latest FB iOS update created much larger “like” buttons, the previous UX had these as smaller icons. Perhaps as more folks were reading Nick’s post on mobile, there were fewer likes per view.